Indian Clarity

Light. Truth. Clarity.

Loading ad...
Sports

CFP Anger Index: An absurd farce over Notre Dame, Miami

playHow the CFP committee landed on putting Miami ahead of Notre Dame (3:28)College Football Playoff selection committee chair Hunter Yurachek discusses the decision to put Miami in the College Football Playoff over Notre Dame. (3:28)David HaleDec 7, 2025, 02:52 PM ETCloseCollege football reporter. Joined ESPN in 2012. Graduate of the University of Delaware. Follow on XEmailPrintOpen Extended ReactionsTwelve years into the College Football Playoff, the committee may have been tasked with its toughest decision yet. On one hand, there's Alabama, the bluest of blue bloods, a team that played the sixth-toughest schedule in the country, with seven wins over FPI top-40 opponents, and whose final loss -- the one that put the Tide squarely on the bubble -- came in the SEC championship game, while others like Miami and Notre Dame sat at home. On the other hand, there's Notre Dame, the most storied program in the sport's history with a legion of fans from coast to coast. The Irish are playing exceptional football, winning 10 straight all by double digits, and their lone losses, way back in August and early September, came to two other top-tier teams by a combined four points. Then on the metaphorical third hand is Miami, a team that began the season with fireworks, sagged in the middle, then responded to its No.

CFP Anger Index: An absurd farce over Notre Dame, Miami

Credit: Go

Key Highlights

  • 18 placement in the first set of rankings by reeling off four straight wins by an average of 27 points per game.
  • Oh, and Miami holds a head-to-head win over Notre Dame, albeit one that came in the first week of the season and that the committee may or may not consider from week to week. Spread around a few garnishes of Texas, Vanderbilt and BYU on the plate and add a dessert course of a Duke-JMU argument that could result in bumping a Power 4 conference from the playoff entirely and it's a tough year to be a committee member. There have been others, of course.
  • In 2014, the committee punted on a tricky Baylor-TCU debate in favor of Ohio State, and the Buckeyes won it all.
  • In 2017, amid a chaotic final week, the committee handed its final bid to Alabama, despite its absence from the SEC championship game, and the Tide went on to win a championship.
  • In 2023, the committee snubbed an undefeated Florida State, because of an injury to QB Jordan Travis, and the Seminoles have gone on to lose 18 of their next 25 games. The results after a controversial decision always seem to lead to the same conclusion: The committee got things right. And yet, as the committee so often notes after each rankings release, the results alone don't tell the whole story.
Loading ad...

Sources

  1. CFP Anger Index: An absurd farce over Notre Dame, Miami

This quick summary is automatically generated using AI based on reports from multiple news sources. The content has not been reviewed or verified by humans. For complete details, accuracy, and context, please refer to the original published articles.

Related Stories

Loading ad...